Journal Entry #14
The more information someone gives back to you is the best way to run the peer reviews workshops. I’ve had some peer reviews in the past where someone will read my paper and only put “good job” on the comments section. What good does that do? It’s like having a golf instructor say “good swing” after every attempt, even though you hook or slice the ball horribly.
Saying that last part, I hope that I have never written “good job” on someone’s paper. More importantly, I hope that if someone puts “good job,” there should be some more written critiques to go along with it.
Peer reviews are a good way for students to learn to be good editors. Someday I’m going to apply what I have learned with the peer review experience when I review my own children’s English papers.
